Carrie Underwood is learning that judging American Idol is far tougher than performing on it.
Two decades after winning the competition, the 42-year-old country superstar has returned to the show—this time as a judge replacing pop icon Katy Perry. But instead of being welcomed with open arms, she’s been met with harsh criticism from fans, co-stars, and show insiders who believe she’s simply not cut out for the role.
Carrie Underwood called too ‘blah’ and ‘boring’ for Idol reboot
Fans have taken to social media to voice frustration over Underwood’s overly gentle critiques. According to one longtime viewer, she’s too nice for the job and lacks the spark needed to hold attention. Another fan described her presence as blah and boring.
Sources inside the show echoed those concerns. An industry insider claimed that even her fellow judges, Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan, have rolled their eyes over her constant pity parties. They added that Carrie’s habit of defending even the most off-key contestants with remarks like “But he’s so cute!” is wearing thin on the panel.
Sa isang insider, sinabi niyang kahit si Lionel ay nagsabi kay Carrie na masyado siyang mabait sa mga contestants.
Producers regret choosing Carrie over edgier Miley Cyrus
Behind the scenes, showrunners are reportedly experiencing buyer’s remorse. According to a production source, Miley Cyrus was the top choice to replace Katy Perry, but her steep contract demands led producers to pivot to Underwood, who signed on for a significantly lower fee.
Executives now believe they made a mistake. One source said Miley’s edginess and personality would’ve made for a more exciting show. The same insider claimed they underestimated the impact of Carrie’s low-drama persona, which they now see as a mismatch for a reality competition show hungry for bold entertainment.
Carrie’s presence, while rooted in good intentions, hasn’t stopped American Idol’s ratings from sliding. Producers fear her lack of fire could further alienate audiences already drifting away from the once-dominant series.
Carrie’s diva behavior on set raises tension
Beyond the judging table, Underwood is also reportedly clashing with production staff. She’s been described as overly sensitive about everything from makeup and wardrobe to camera angles and studio temperature.
Isang source ang nagsabing madalas daw nagrereklamo si Carrie sa set—sa ilaw, sa aircon, at sa suot niyang damit.
Despite having signed a multiyear contract, insiders believe she could exit the show early if she doesn’t adjust. As another source bluntly put it, Carrie may be one-and-done if she can’t toughen up.
With fans tuning out and producers looking for ways to revive interest, Underwood’s future on American Idol remains uncertain.
Jaja has a degree in journalism and took classes in international law and business communication. Her career spans roles at prominent international media outlets, including International Business Times, Celebeat and Delightful Philippines. As a news editor, Jaja covered a wide range of beats, including legal, business, economy, cryptocurrency, personal finance, gaming, technology, and entertainment.