O.J. Simpson’s estate is suing his son, Justin Simpson, over claims that he wrongfully moved into the late NFL star’s home and refuses to vacate. The lawsuit, filed by the estate’s special administrator, Malcolm LaVergne, alleges that Justin took possession of the property following Simpson’s April 2024 death despite the estate’s intention to liquidate it and settle outstanding debts.
The legal battle over the luxurious Florida home is the latest twist in the contentious administration of Simpson’s estate, which is struggling with over $30 million in debts, including a wrongful death judgment owed to the families of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman.
Estate Accuses Justin Simpson of Illegal Occupation
According to the lawsuit, the property was purchased through Primary Holdings, LLC, a company linked to Justin. LaVergne claims that while Primary Holdings acquired the house to protect Simpson’s financial interests, O.J. personally made all payments, and the property was never meant to be separated from his estate.
Despite these claims, Justin reportedly moved into the house shortly after his father’s death, asserting his ownership and refusing to vacate or compensate the estate for past payments. The estate, however, maintains that O.J.’s will did not designate the home for Justin’s personal use.
“This is a clear violation of O.J.’s estate plan,” a source close to the matter told Today’s Esquire. “The estate needs to sell assets to pay off significant debts, and this dispute is delaying the process.”
Adding to the controversy, Justin already owns another home nearby, though it is reportedly less extravagant than the disputed property.
Simpson’s Estate Struggles With Massive Debt
Simpson’s financial troubles did not end with his death. His estate is grappling with a $100 million wrongful death judgment, which has ballooned due to accrued interest. The judgment was awarded to the families of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman after Simpson was found liable in a 1997 civil trial.
Additionally, the estate faces significant tax liens and creditor claims from the IRS and California Tax Board, further complicating efforts to resolve the financial mess left behind.
LaVergne has already begun liquidating Simpson’s assets, including auctioning memorabilia and personal items tied to his controversial legacy. Some of these auctions have included prison-era possessions, such as Simpson’s collection of adult magazines, which garnered attention in the media.
Despite the estate’s efforts, the legal dispute with Justin Simpson could prolong the settlement process, potentially delaying payouts to creditors and beneficiaries.
“O.J. Simpson’s estate is a financial minefield,” an estate law expert told Today’s Esquire. “If the court sides with the estate, Justin could be forced out—and possibly required to pay restitution.”
For now, Justin remains in the disputed home, and the case is expected to play out in court in the coming months.
Jaja has a degree in journalism and took classes in international law and business communication. Her career spans roles at prominent international media outlets, including International Business Times, Celebeat and Delightful Philippines. As a news editor, Jaja covered a wide range of beats, including legal, business, economy, cryptocurrency, personal finance, gaming, technology, and entertainment.