Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes may be dreaming of a star-studded wedding in the Hamptons, but insiders say their guest list is turning into a public relations nightmare.
The former Good Morning America co-hosts, who ignited headlines after their romantic relationship was exposed in late 2022, are now reportedly planning a high-profile wedding. However, their hopes for an A-list turnout may be dashed as friends and former colleagues show little interest in attending.
Celeb guest list hits a wall
Sources say Robach, 52, and Holmes, 47, are determined to tie the knot in a glamorous, over-the-top celebration meant to cement their place in celebrity circles. One insider shared that they’ve told friends a wedding is finally happening — and it’s expected to be one of the biggest events of the year.
“They want a wedding that screams status,” a source close to the couple explained. “They’re reaching out to TV stars, Broadway names, and high-profile personalities — including Michael Strahan, Robin Roberts, and Sara Haines — to help validate their brand.”
Amy was seen wearing a sparkling ring on her left hand during the iHeartRadio Music Awards on March 17, sparking rumors of an engagement. But despite the buzz, the enthusiasm among invited guests appears lukewarm at best.
“There’s already talk of people making excuses not to attend,” a tipster revealed. “Many see them as overexposed thanks to their podcast and feel the couple hasn’t shown much humility after their exit from ABC.”
Reputation issues cast a shadow
Both Robach and Holmes were previously married when their relationship came to light. Their controversial coupling cost them their GMA3 hosting gigs, and their subsequent efforts to rebrand through a podcast have faced mixed reactions.
“The truth is, they’re not taken seriously in many circles anymore,” said a source. “They’re seen as a scandal-driven couple clinging to fame. A lot of people think this wedding is more about image than love.”
While some believe a more private ceremony might help the couple start fresh, others say the pair remains committed to a public spectacle.
“They would honestly have more success if they eloped,” one insider said. “But they’re convinced this big wedding is their chance to rewrite the narrative. They’re not backing down — even if most of the seats stay empty.”
Despite the pushback, the couple is moving forward with planning. A final date has not been confirmed, but the wedding is expected to take place later this year in the Hamptons.
Jaja has a degree in journalism and took classes in international law and business communication. Her career spans roles at prominent international media outlets, including International Business Times, Celebeat and Delightful Philippines. As a news editor, Jaja covered a wide range of beats, including legal, business, economy, cryptocurrency, personal finance, gaming, technology, and entertainment.