Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesperson, Atty. Paolo Panelo, said it was already “too late” for Senate Impeachment Court Presiding Officer Chiz Escudero to remind senator-judges to respect witnesses’ rights and maintain fairness during the impeachment proceedings.
Panelo said the treatment of witnesses during the trial had already caused damage, expressing concern that the questioning of some senator-judges could discourage other defense witnesses from appearing before the impeachment court.
“The damage has been done to the witnesses,” Panelo said.
He warned that succeeding defense witnesses might become hesitant to testify if what he described as hostile questioning by some senator-judges continued.
Panelo advised upcoming defense witnesses to prepare themselves for similar questioning when they appear before the court. He also expressed hope that the senator-judges would follow Escudero’s reminder.
Escudero earlier urged senator-judges and lawyers to exercise restraint when questioning witnesses and respect their right to protection from improper or insulting treatment.
He emphasized that unsatisfactory answers from witnesses do not automatically constitute contempt of court.
“The Chair wishes to emphasize that an answer which may be unsatisfactory is not inherently contemptible,” Escudero said.
Escudero also cited Supreme Court guidance emphasizing that courts must exercise their contempt powers with the highest degree of restraint.
His reminder called on members of the impeachment court to observe fairness, dignity and respect throughout the proceedings, particularly when dealing with witnesses.
Panelo’s remarks highlighted concerns from the vice president’s camp over the treatment of defense witnesses and the possible effect of questioning practices on those expected to testify in the ongoing impeachment trial.
The exchange comes as the Senate impeachment court continues proceedings on the case against Duterte, with Escudero reminding its members of their responsibility to uphold proper courtroom conduct and protect witnesses’ rights.
