Senate court approves show cause order vs. Panelo

The Senate impeachment court has approved a motion to issue a show cause order against lawyer Paolo Panelo, spokesperson for Vice President Sara Duterte, following remarks questioned by Sen. Erwin Tulfo.

Presiding Officer Chiz Escudero approved Tulfo’s motion after the senator raised concerns over Panelo’s statement on Wednesday, which he said appeared to show disrespect toward the impeachment court.

Tulfo argued that although Panelo is not a respondent in the impeachment case, his comments about the senator-judges were inappropriate, particularly because his principal, Duterte, is facing proceedings before the court.

In response, Panelo welcomed the opportunity to explain his remarks, maintaining that his statements were fair, made in good faith and protected by the Constitution.

In a statement dated Nov. 20, Panelo cited Supreme Court rulings, including Garcia Jr. v. Manrique and Tolentino v. Heydarian, to support his position that citizens have the right to criticize public officials and judicial actions.

He argued that the power of contempt should not prevent public scrutiny of courts or suppress legitimate criticism and democratic discourse.

Panelo also maintained that his comments did not impede, obstruct or degrade the administration of justice.

He said he would formally respond to the show cause order within the prescribed period upon receiving it.

The show cause order gives Panelo an opportunity to explain why his remarks should not warrant further action from the impeachment court.